5 Valentine's Day Foods You Should Be Making, Not Buying

Welcome to Thrifty. A weekly column where assistant nutrition editor and registered dietitian, Jessica Ball, keeps it real on how to grocery shop on a budget, make healthy meals for one or two, and make earth-friendly choices without overhauling your entire life.

This year, I am craving a low-maintenance Valentine's Day. My boyfriend and I will be hunkered down with a nice bottle of wine and lots of homemade foods that will be enjoyed in sweatpants. No makeup, no jewelry. And honestly, I'm here for it. Whether Valentine's Day falls on a weekday or a weekend, sometimes it's more meaningful to celebrate it at home, free from the pressures and commercialization that can come with the holiday. You can enjoy it with housemates, friends or solo—however you want.

5 Valentine's Day Foods You Should Be Making, Not Buying

Here are some of my favorite foods to create an entire meal, from appetizers and dinner to dessert, making February 14th feel special without breaking the bank or taking the whole day.

1. Chocolate-Covered Strawberries

This Valentine's Day classic is every bit as delicious as it is cliché. Ordering chocolate-dipped strawberries from the store can get expensive, and it can be hard to make sure the strawberries are fresh and flavorful. Luckily for us, this delicacy is easy to make at home. Simply melt chocolate, swirl the berries in it and you're done. Add flair by soaking the strawberries in prosecco beforehand.

2. Cheese Plate

A cheese plate is an elegant touch to any evening, Valentine's Day included. It is perfect for munching while you sip on something and slowly make dinner. Plus, it helps take the edge off so nobody gets hangry, which (if you're like me) could derail a romantic night. It feels like you're out at a fancy restaurant and makes the evening feel like an event. Learn how to build the best charcuterie board.

3. Surf and/or Turf

Bring an expensive meal you'd enjoy out somewhere fancy into your home for a fraction of the price. Even if the ingredients, like filet mignon or lobster, are more expensive than what you would usually buy for dinner, it will be significantly less pricey than dining out or getting takeout. You can get exactly the cut, size and flavor combos you want as well. If you don't see what you are looking for in the meat section, ask the butcher for help. They may even have cooking tips to help you get the most delicious outcome. If you really want to go big, order a lobster tail bouquet for your loved one and cook the tails together.

4. Cocktails

There are several upsides to being your own bartender: You won't have to wait in line, drinks won't be aggressively priced and it's easier to customize your drink. Mix up a mocktail to mitigate any unwanted symptoms the next day, too. We have ample "romantic" cocktails like our Blood Orange, Gin & Prosecco Cocktail (great if you have leftovers from the strawberries) and the iconic Espresso Martini. Or just have a solo night with Champagne, a good book and fuzzy slippers. That works too.

5. Tarts and Truffles

I am not a dessert baker per se, but for special occasions, I am pretty motivated to go all out. If you want to try something new this V-day, make your own special dessert. Brighten up your desserts with a fruit-forward tart, or add richness to the night with velvety truffles. Recipes like Chocolate Nut Bark are simple while looking fancy and tasting great.

The Bottom Line

There is no wrong way to celebrate Valentine's Day. Whether you are spending time with a significant other, close friends, family or solo, these foods will help you have an elegant evening on a budget. With a little time and planning, you can create your custom menu to make the night memorable.